Pressure Reversals: How to Identify and Understand the Potential Implication to Pipeline Integrity

Cara Macrory-Dalton, PE
Senior Engineer II
Kiefner and Associates, Inc.

 

Introduction

Pressure testing of hazardous liquid and natural gas pipelines is conducted for a variety of reasons, some mandated in U.S. pipeline regulations or industry standards, and others elective. Pressure testing is one requirement for the establishment of maximum operating pressure (MOP) or maximum allowable operating pressure (MAOP). A pressure test can address several integrity threats including:

  • time dependent threats such as internal corrosion, external corrosion, fatigue cracks, and longitudinally-oriented SCC,
  • time-independent (i.e. random) threats such as mechanical damage and outside force damage,
  • manufacturing defects such as longitudinal seam weld defects and laminations, and
  • some construction related defects.

Pressure testing is particularly effective at eliminating longitudinally oriented defects and demonstrating the immediate fitness for service of a pipeline.

Given a potential and sometimes likely outcome of a pressure test is pipeline failure, it is better for a test break or leak to occur with the least amount of impact to public safety and the environment. Therefore, in general, pressure testing is conducted with water (hydrostatic testing) as a means to determine a pipeline’s fitness for service in a controlled, safe manner. Test failures are more likely to occur when an existing pipeline is tested to a hoop stress level in excess of those in prior tests of the pipeline or the pipe manufacturer’s pressure test in the pipe mill. A major cause of such failures is seam manufacturing defects. Older-vintage pipe materials[1] may or may not be a pipeline integrity threat, but the potential for them to contain more manufacturing defects than pipe materials made since 1970 and to have properties inferior to the more recent pipe materials is significant. Therefore, when an existing pipeline containing older-vintage materials is retested, test failures may arise in conjunction with material defects. Furthermore, in the event of multiple failures caused by cracks in the longitudinal seam weld, pressure reversals may occur.

Pressure Reversals

A defect that fails at a pressure level lower than the highest pressure it was previously exposed to during a hydrostatic test signifies the occurrence of a pressure reversal. Pressure reversals can be caused by growth during pressurization and subsequent damage to the defect during depressurization due to plastic strain. The pressure reversal size (Pr) can be expressed as a percentage:

where

Pis the highest level of pressure reached at the test site on any prior pressurization during the current test cycle (psig)

Pf  is the failure pressure at the test site (psig)

If test failures begin to occur and testing is continued, the possibility of encountering pressure reversals arises. If several pressure reversals occur, it may be possible to estimate the likelihood of a pressure reversal of a given size. Studies of actual hydrostatic test cases have shown that an inverse relationship exists between pressure reversal size and the probability of occurrence of the reversal, and the risk of a failure at the operating pressure from a pressure reversal is usually negligible[2].

Considerations for when Pressure Reversals have or are expected to Occur

Prior to any pressure test program, past failures should be studied to determine if pressure reversals have previously occurred, and contingency test plans should be developed[3]. During an ongoing pressure test, information on failures should be studied as they occur for evidence of pressure reversals and comparisons made of their sizes to the margin of safety between test pressure and operating pressure. A test that is terminated by a rupture should not be considered the final test. This circumstance could lead to a pressure reversal occurring upon returning a pipeline to service.

Kiefner has extensive experience in estimating the probability of pressure reversals of a given size occurring, as well as, supporting and providing guidance to pipeline operators on pressure testing, multiple test failures, and safe operating pressure.

 

[1] Older-vintage pipe is generally regarded as line pipe manufactured at a time when little or no attempt was made to enhance ductile toughness, when the quality and properties of longitudinal seams often were inferior to those of the parent pipe material, and no requirement was imposed on the manufacturer for nondestructive inspection of either the seams or the pipe body. In particular, pipe materials manufactured using seam-fabricating processes such as single-submerged-arc welding, low-frequency ERW, furnace lap-welding, or furnace butt-welding are considered to be particularly more likely to cause hydrostatic test failures than modern materials.

[2] Kiefner, J.F., Kolovich, K.M, and Kariyawasam, S. A Study of Hydrostatic Tests Where Multiple Test Failures Have Occurred. Proceedings of the 8th International Pipeline Conference, IPC2010. September 27-October 1, 2010.

[3] A contingency plan is any pre-defined alternative to the original pressure test plan that is implemented after some criteria are met during the execution of the original test plan. Adjustment to the test plan could include changing the target test pressure, test segmentation, or intended operating pressure.

Comments are closed.

UPDATE ON COVID-19: APPLUS+ IS AN ESSENTIAL AND CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE SERVICE PROVIDER & OPEN FOR BUSINESS

Applus+ is a specialist service provider of non-destructive examination and inspection services which are critical to ensuring the safety and integrity of the energy and industrial sector. Accordingly, please be informed that Applus+ and its affiliate companies, including but not limited to Applus RTD USA, Inc., Applus Velosi America, LLC, Applus K2 America, LLC, and Kiefner and Associates, Inc. are open for business.

Applus+ is deemed as an Essential and Critical Infrastructure service provider. The services provided by Applus+ ensure our client’s continuous safe operations, delivery of essential services to our end clients in these times of need, and supports compliance with local, state, and federal regulations—include our united mandate to continue providing Essential and Critical Infrastructure services.

Operating for over 85 years, Applus+ has responded to emergency situations in high consequence areas and at times when other suppliers have been unable to perform. We believe that we have not only demonstrated value but sincere commitment to quality and service. Applus+ will continue to show its unwavering support at the request of our clients to assist in maintaining operational continuity.

We would like to let you know what measures Applus+ is taking to ensure the health and safety of our employees, clients and suppliers.  We have activated our Business Continuity Plan and the purpose of this Plan is to ensure uninterrupted service. As the situation develops, our management and protocols will be adjusted, as required.

Applus+ has taken the following measures:

  • Active implementation of Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) protocols.
  • Provided information to employees about the Coronavirus, its symptoms, and how to minimize its spread. Employees have been advised to avoid crowded areas and to limit social interaction, and have been trained on the correct hygiene, health and safety procedures.
  • Internal protocols have been implemented to follow all CDC guidelines for all who:
    • Have travelled internationally within the last 14 days
    • Have been in close contact with someone who has been confirmed infected with or is being tested for COVID-19
    • Have been in close contact with someone who is under self-quarantine.
    • Have any symptoms such as fever, coughing, and shortness of breath.
  • Effective 03/17/2020 short-term remote work guidelines for employees have been implemented.
  • Applus+ has increased the frequency of cleaning services in our facilities to ensure a clean and safe working environment.
  • Travel has been limited to essential client-required travel only, with severe restrictions in the case of high-risk destinations.

We will continue to monitor the situation in order to adapt in a timely and effective manner as the situation evolves. Our goal is to ensure that we fulfil our commitment to our clients and deliver the highest standards of service excellence, while at the same time keeping our workforce safe and healthy.

As always, you should feel free to contact us with any questions. Please email the team at contracts.na@applus.com for further assistance regarding the COVID-19 matter. To schedule services, continue to communicate with your Applus+ representative.

Thank you for your support and partnership,

Applus+ Management Team